An elegant Lincoln Park-style mansion living room with a limestone fireplace, cream seating, walnut floors and tall windows overlooking a private late-autumn brick-walled garden.

Two Lincoln Park Mansions on Burling Street Sold at Nearly the Same Price per Foot in 2026

In September 2025, a five-bedroom house at 1964 N. Burling Street went on the market for $6.5 million. Seven days later it was under contract at full price. A few blocks south, 1853 N. Burling Street had already been on the market since April of that year. It started at about $9.5 million, came back at $8.995 million and finally closed in early November 2026 for $8.3 million. That was the highest-priced home sale in Chicago so far this year, according to Crain's Chicago Business.

Measured by the square foot, buyers paid nearly the same for both houses, even though one sold in a week and the other waited a year and a half.

Two houses on Burling, $2 a square foot apart

The Real Deal reported that the 6,800-square-foot house at 1964 N. Burling closed in February 2026 at $956 a square foot. The sellers had bought the lot next door years earlier, so the house sits on a 50-by-123-foot parcel with a lawn, a patio and rooftop decks.

The house at 1853 N. Burling is bigger and newer. It has seven bedrooms in about 8,700 square feet, was built in 2010 on a 44-foot-wide lot, and has an elevator, a sport court and an attached heated garage. Traded's deal record puts the $8.3 million sale at $954 a square foot, 12% below the original asking price, after 18 months on the market.

Run the asking prices through the same math. At $9.45 million, the first ask on 1853 N. Burling came to roughly $1,086 a square foot, and the $8.995 million relist was still about $1,034. Buyers paid $954. That is the same figure they paid for a house on the same street that sold at full price in its first week. The higher ask did not get the seller more per foot. It added about 18 months of waiting before the house sold at the going rate.

Two sales are a small sample, and the houses differ in age, lot and layout. Still, two buyers paid within $2 a square foot of each other on the same street, and this year's top-tier deals keep showing the same pattern.

The rest of the top tier in 2026

The other big Lincoln Park sales reported this year took different routes to closing.

Address How it sold Asking price Sale price Per sq. ft.
1964 N. Burling St. Public listing, under contract in 7 days $6.5M $6.5M $956
1853 N. Burling St. Public listing, about 18 months, one relist about $9.5M $8.3M $954
1838 N. Cleveland Ave. Agents-only private network, listed July 21 $5.5M $5.0M about $714
1722 N. Burling St. Off-market None published $6.1M Not reported

The Cleveland Avenue house closed in October. The six-bedroom, roughly 7,000-square-foot home sold about 9% under its $5.5 million ask after being marketed through an agents-only network instead of a broad public launch. At about $714 a square foot, it closed well below the Burling figures. Location within Lincoln Park, the lot and the way a house is marketed all affect what buyers will pay per foot, so the Burling pair should be treated as a benchmark for one street, not a citywide rule.

Across the four sales, the pattern is that a house priced near what recent comparable sales support moved quickly, and a house priced well above that waited and then sold at about that level anyway. None of these sellers got a premium over the going rate by asking for one.

Why the middle of Lincoln Park's market looks so different

The typical Lincoln Park house runs on another set of numbers. MLS data for October 2026 shows 12 detached single-family closings in Lincoln Park at a $2.45 million median, up 23% from October 2025. Median market time was 10 days, and homes sold for 104% of list price on average. As of Nov. 16 there were 23 detached homes for sale, which works out to 1.9 months of supply. Condos moved faster in the same month. There were 68 condo closings at a $757,500 median, 7 days on market and 102% of list, with 86 active listings and 1.3 months of supply.

This spring the competition was sharper. The Real Deal reported in April that in an area covering Lincoln Park, Lakeview, Wicker Park and Bucktown, about 70% of publicly listed homes over $500,000 that closed between March 9 and April 6 sold above asking. Among those that went over, the average premium was 7.8%.

The long-run data shows a steady market. DePaul University's Institute for Housing Studies, in its second-quarter 2026 price index released Oct. 15, found that single-family prices in the combined Lake View/Lincoln Park submarket rose 10.6% from a year earlier. That was the second-largest annual gain in Cook County, and the median single-family sale was $1,538,000. The same report shows the submarket's price growth since early 2020 at 33.4%, among the smallest in the county. Lake View/Lincoln Park was also the only area in Cook County without a sharp price drop during the last recession, and IHS describes its smaller rebound as a sign of stability.

That stability is what makes a price-per-foot benchmark useful at the top. In the middle tier, several buyers are often chasing each house, so competition can push a price past recent sales. At $6 million and up, a listing may only need one buyer, and that buyer knows what the last comparable house on the block sold for. A seller asking above that level is waiting for a buyer willing to pay more than the last one did, and the 1853 N. Burling sale shows how long that can take.

A builder is testing the ceiling on Seminary Avenue

One project this fall is priced above the Burling benchmark on purpose. Old Head Development bought 2018 N. Seminary Avenue for $2.5 million in May and tore down the 1890s workers cottage on the lot over the summer, Hoodline reported. The planned seven-bedroom, 7,200-square-foot house is listed at $7.3 million, or about $1,007 a square foot. It is expected to be finished in spring or summer 2027, with a brick and limestone front, a three-car garage and a floor plan the buyer can still adjust.

That asking price is about 5% above what buyers paid on Burling. The builder's case for the premium is the lot. The parcel is 37.5 feet wide, half again as wide as the standard 25-foot Chicago lot. "The width of the home is kind of the biggest selling point," the listing broker told The Real Deal. He also told Hoodline that five to ten buyers are waiting for every new lot that comes up in the neighborhood.

The Burling sales suggest a way to judge that bet. A premium over the going rate has to come from something buyers can't find in the last comparable sale, such as extra lot width or a layout they help design. The 1964 N. Burling house had that kind of advantage in its double-width parcel, and it still sold at about the same per-foot rate as its neighbor. That is a high bar for any seller asking more than the street has paid.

What this means if you are buying or selling at this level

If you're selling a Lincoln Park house in the multimillion-dollar range, the asking price mostly sets how long you wait. Pricing near what recent comparable sales support got the 1964 N. Burling house a full-price contract in a week. Pricing roughly $130 a square foot higher kept 1853 N. Burling on the market for 18 months before it closed at the going rate. Your timeline, carrying costs and plans for your next home all depend on that waiting period, so set the asking price with it in mind.

Buyers can read the same sales from the other side. At this level, a year or more on the market says more than a single price cut, and the block's recent comparable sales show how far a long-listed house's ask sits above what buyers have paid. Houses near the middle of the market follow the October numbers, selling in about 10 days at over list price.

Questions buyers and sellers ask about Lincoln Park's top tier

Do Lincoln Park luxury homes usually sell below asking? Not as a rule. In 2026, 1964 N. Burling sold at full price in a week, while 1853 N. Burling and 1838 N. Cleveland closed below their asks. The difference followed how each house was priced, not the size of the price.

Is price per square foot a reliable guide in Lincoln Park? It works best for nearby houses on similar blocks. The two Burling sales landed within $2 a square foot of each other, while the Cleveland Avenue house closed at about $714. Location within the neighborhood, lot width and marketing all change the figure.

How tight is single-family inventory right now? There were 23 detached homes for sale in Lincoln Park as of Nov. 16, against 12 closings in October, or about 1.9 months of supply.

If you own a Lincoln Park home in this price range, the asking price will shape your timeline more than your final number. The team at Chicago Home Partner can pull the recent comparable sales for your block and show you what buyers have actually paid per square foot. Schedule a complimentary market consultation, or browse current Lincoln Park homes for sale to see where today's listings are priced against those benchmarks.

Find Your Next Dream Home

Browse Homes

WORK WITH AN EXPERT

Buying or selling a home is one of the largest financial decisions we make in our lives. It represents not only a place to live but also a significant part of your overall financial portfolio. Our proven track record of success sets us apart in an ever-changing and competitive marketplace. We would be honored to discuss your current situation and advise you on how we can best help you achieve your goals.